TAXES


TIARA SUPPORTS


  • Progressive taxation

  • Capital Gains Tax

  • Expanding the EITC

Read time: 5 minutes


THE CURRENT SYSTEM IS BROKEN


Our tax code is extremely regressive. Our state’s wealthiest residents shoulder a far lighter tax burden than everybody else. In Rhode Island, the poorest 20% (people who make less than $21,700 annually) pay 12.1% of their annual income in state and local taxes.[1] The richest 1% (people who make over $467,700 annually) pay only 7.9% of their annual income in state and local taxes.[2] Everybody in the middle pays between 9% and 10%.[3] Clearly, Rhode Island’s richest residents are not paying their fair share.

This did not happen by accident. Over the past few decades, the super-rich have steadily made our tax code more and more regressive by buying off corrupt politicians, persuading them to cut taxes for the 1% again and again. For example, in 2006, the state passed a tax reform package that included, among other things, a large reduction on the marginal tax rate applied to the richest 1%. This tax cut for the top 1% has already cost Rhode Island well over a billion dollars in lost revenue over the last thirteen years.[4] This has caused immense damage to our state. Our public schools are crumbling, our roads and bridges are poorly maintained, our transition to clean energy is too slow, our job training and childcare programs are inadequate, and our public health services are woefully underfunded—all because the super-rich insist on paying lower taxes than the rest of us.


THE 1% MUST PAY THEIR FAIR SHARE


This ends now. Rhode Island must create a new tax bracket for the top 1% and raise the marginal tax rate on this group from 5.99% to 10.99%. Every member of the top 1% in Rhode Island earns over $467,700 per year.[5] On average, each member of the top 1% in this state has an annual income of $1,123,300.[6] Our proposed reform would charge them just five more cents for every dollar they make over $467,700 in a given year. This proposal would generate over $170 million each year.[7] Our plan will help to reverse the enormous damage that perpetual tax cuts on the 1% have wrought on our state. By ensuring that the wealthiest 1% begin to pay their fair share, Rhode Island will generate money needed to improve our schools, roads, job training programs, public health, and clean energy transition. This is a crucial step towards creating an economy that works for all Rhode Islanders, not just the 1%.


THE PUBLIC SUPPORTS ENSURING THAT THE RICH PAY THEIR FAIR SHARE


62% of Americans believe that the rich pay too little in taxes.[8] This belief is consistent and longstanding. For decades, polling has indicated that a majority of Americans—and usually a large majority—believe that the wealthy should be taxed more heavily.[9] The idea is especially popular among Democrats. Research suggests that 75% of Democrats believe that the rich should pay higher taxes.[10] And 62% of self-identified Independents feel the same way.[11] In Rhode Island, where Democrats substantially outnumber Republicans, our elected officials have no excuse not to heed the clear wishes of the public and force the very wealthy to begin paying their fair share. The Rhode Island Political Cooperative will finally give this majority a voice and promote a progressive tax system that works for the benefit of the many, not the few.


THE RICH WILL NOT LEAVE


When confronted with the possibility that the state might raise their taxes, the ultra-rich routinely threaten to leave. This is an empty threat. Different states already tax the rich at very different rates. So if they wanted to move to a state with a lower tax burden, they already have the ability to do so. But it turns out that the super-rich move less frequently than everyone else, despite the fact that they have the option of moving to lower-tax states. In an average year, only 2.4% of American millionaires move to another state, whereas the general population has a migration rate of 2.9% per year.[12] Furthermore, millionaires receive a net tax advantage only 15% of the time that they do move to another state.[13] This means that, in any given year, only about 0.3% of American millionaires actually move to a state with a lower tax burden.[14] Moreover, three of the five states with the highest concentration of super-wealthy individuals impose an additional, specific tax on their millionaire residents.[15]

A moment’s reflection suggests that this data is actually quite unsurprising. People choose where to live based on a myriad of factors, and the relative tax advantage of different states is only one of them. Additionally, the typical millionaire is not young, which means that they are likely to have a longstanding social network that makes it inconvenient for them to move. Most importantly, the majority of millionaires are married and have children at home.[16] These family responsibilities make interstate migration unattractive.


THIS WILL IMPROVE OUR ECONOMY


Contrary to the claims made by the ultra-rich and their political allies, raising taxes on multimillionaires will actually improve our economy. By raising taxes on the 1%, Rhode Island can generate revenue necessary to improve education, job training, childcare, infrastructure, and public health. These are investments that matter a great deal to talented young people who are deciding where to live. Unlike the super-rich, who are largely older and settled, young people are far less likely to be tied to a specific state. In fact, young college graduates are the most mobile group in the country. A recent college graduate is four times more likely than the average millionaire to move to a new state.[17] Ensuring that the top 1% pay their fair share will allow us to invest in repairing our infrastructure, launching new job training programs, and improving our education system. This will make Rhode Island more attractive to young and highly skilled prospective residents, as well as the businesses that rely on them, contributing to a more vibrant and dynamic economy.

TIARA SUPPORTS THE TAX FAIRNESS POLICY, AND WOULD ADD TWO MORE POLICIES TO HER PLATFORM:

CAPITAL GAINS TAX & EXPANDING THE EITC


CAPITAL GAINS TAX


In Rhode Island, the highest capital gains tax is only 6%. While reforming the income tax system and increasing the burden on the rich will fight some inequality, much of the 1% 's money comes from passive income, rather than active income. Through stock portfolios, real estate, and more, rich people can afford to have a salary of zero, and a massive return on capital gains, and only pay the 6% tax. This is a glaring loophole in the Rhode Island tax system, and it’s time to change it. Tiara supports legislation that would increase the capital gains rate to 10%, ensuring that Rhode Island’s richest cannot cheat the system and avoid paying their fair share.


EXPANDING THE EITC


The Earned Income Tax Credit gives low-income families the ability to meet basic needs. The EITC is in particular beneficial to Black and brown people, and women. In Rhode Island, the EITC is 15% of the federal EITC. However, in 2014, it was at 25%, before the state legislature cut it. It is clear that many in our government don’t truly care about providing aid to low-income members of our community. Tiara is going to fight to change that, by advocating for an increase to 25% of the federal EITC in her first year in office. In addition, she wants to create a Child Tax Credit that will provide up to an additional $1000 to families with children.